Everyday another story surfaces regarding the Mitchell Report and the athletes listed in it. Everyone knows drugs are wrong. Everyone knows the side effects of these drugs. Yet, as more and more drama unfolds surrounding baseball’s performance-enhancing drug scandal no one has bothered to examine why these players would take them in the first place.
In a recently released book, The Lucifer Effect, Philip Zimbardo, Ph.D. outlines the reasons why individuals can act against their morals perpetuating seemingly inexplicable acts. His trademark experiment involved taking normal college students and splitting them into two groups, guards and prisoners. A simple coin flip decided the roles but what transpired explains the dark side of human nature.
It took less than a week for the experiment to spiral out of control. The students quickly departed from their normal behavior and took on the roles of their characters. Guards abused the prisoners physically and emotionally while prisoners acted as though they were truly incarcerated. Zimbardo cut the cord on the experiment because of increasing safety and health concerns for all participants.
The take away from this experiment is that good, well-adjusted people can do horrible things without even thinking what they are doing is wrong. The observed behavior is a direct result to the expectations of the environment. Or, said anther way, one acts based on what their perceived role requires of them. To apply this reasoning to baseball, college sports and high school sports it is no wonder athletes take harmful drugs to boost performance.
The situation frames the thinking of the participants. If a great athlete, who leads his team, sees or hears of others gaining an advantage then they will most likely mimic to maintain their social ranking. While the players in question must face penalties for their wrongs, one cannot place the complete blame on them alone. Baseball as a whole must be examined to shift the values. Major League Baseball (and its commissioner) must face the scrutiny as Roger Clemens if the outcome desired is a positive solution.




Entries (RSS)